Audrey G.

Elizabeth Compared to the Boy

In my opinion I think Elizabeth from Molly’s Pilgrim  and the boy from The Giving Tree  they both are rude.

Elizabeth  has many examples that she is rude. Elizabeth would make fun of Molly’s accent and her voice. This is rude because she can’t choose her voice. Another way I can prove she is rude is Elizabeth would make fun of Molly’s face and look. This is rude because everyone looks different, and no one is ugly. My final piece of evidence is Elizabeth once followed Molly home one day singing a mean song. This is rude because she’s acting like a bully.

The boy isn’t just rude but also selfish, if you observe closely you may see it too. One way I know the boy is rude is, the boy kept taking stuff from the tree he used to love. Another way I know he is rude is he  even takes most of the tree’s body. Another way I know he is rude is rude is he never said thank you. this shows he is rude because he just walks away with part of her body. My last piece of evidence is the boy never gave the tree stuff in return. This is rude because the Tree gave the boy so much and the boy didn’t give anything.

This is why I think  Elizabeth and the Boy are both rude, but in different ways. There are more ways they are rude but here are some. But they both learned they have to care for other people too.